Laptops are horizontal; phones are vertical
Obvious, right? If you’re taking a photo for a laptop, you might want to shoot horizontal. For a phone, vertical.
Landscapes are horizontal; portraits are vertical
Before there were phones and laptops, vertical and horizontal compositions already meant something. Landscapes tended to be horizontal. Portraits tended to be vertical.
Film is Cinemascope; Television is Closeup
From Academy Aspect Ratio, to Cinemascope, to Ultra Panavision, film formats have grown ever more horizontal, ever more widescreen. Television, the small screen, tended to feature close-up images since historically TV screens were much smaller.
Scale is as important in photography as aspect ratio. A closeup of a person or a donut that looks great on Instagram might be boring blown up to a 40″x60″ print. And conversely, a busy scene of people interacting or dancers filling a stage that is vibrant and breathtaking in that 40″x60″ print, might be chaotic, lacking focus, and uninteresting on Instagram.
Street Photography is Landscape?
This one is obviously personal opinion, but for me, Street Photography is about landscapes. Landscapes of People! It’s all about the people for me, but it’s not so much about portraiture as it is about people interacting. Usually, people interacting with other people. A person interacting with an environment would also tend to be a landscape for me. In another photographic genre, we’d call that an Environmental Portrait. A portrait-portrait, a headshot, might well be vertical. But an environmental portrait, a person in a scene, feels landscape for me.
I shoot Streetscapes
If you asked me to shoot a headshot for you, I might shoot it vertical. But for almost everything else, I shoot horizontal. For all the reasons above:
- I like the larger screens of laptops and desktops more than the portability of phones
- I do photograph people, but I think of them more as landscapes of people interacting than as headshots
- Today any photograph might be viewed on any size or aspect ratio device. And I select a suitable subset of the images I capture to post on Instagram. But I think in terms of larger, more richly nuanced images on larger screens.
- I bought a 65″ “television” because I don’t watch television. I don’t watch TV, but I also don’t make paper prints anymore. A 65″ “monitor” or “digital picture frame” is a great way to experience depth and detail in photography.
I crop for Instagram
100 times more people will see my work on IG than will ever make it here to my website. Instagram, at least this week, is the new Town Square. But it’s still nice, still important, to have a Painter’s Studio, or Writer’s Studio, or Pamphleteer’s Workshop, to work through and refine the bits that eventually make it to the marketplace of ideas that is that town square. For me, that Studio or Workshop is my website (this website). So I shoot horizontal for this website.
Instagram was born a square, 1:1, format. But today you can post glorious 5:4 vertical images there. That 25% larger IG image on a small phone is dramatic! You can also post ridiculously tiny horizontals on IG, don’t ask me why you’d want to. If there’s a horizontal image on this website that I really love, but that can’t be cropped to a 5:4 vertical, then it won’t be posted on IG. Which is fine.